Every Sunday, churches all over America post a clip. Forty seconds, the best line from the sermon, white text over the preacher mid-gesture, a caption with a few emojis. By Monday it has a few thousand views, and by Tuesday it may have even gone viral. Somebody makes those clips, and I've been wondering what else comes off the same factory line.
I get why churches do it. More people see it, a stranger in some other time zone watches it on her lunch break, and maybe she hears something that changes her life. I believe that can happen, and I believe it does.
But the clip didn't do that. The word of God did. It never comes back empty, and it works through a reel or a tract, and it can even work through a street corner preacher. Isaiah says it's like the rain and the snow that water the earth so that it gives seed to the sower and bread to the eater (Isaiah 55:10-11).
Sometimes we end up giving the credit to the wrong place, and a church that thinks the factory line is working has every reason to keep it running.
•••
The reality is that short clips and sound bites are a lot of how the work of the church gets done these days. If you follow any church on Instagram, that's what your feed looks like, and none of it is bad in itself. But a feed rewards things that last and travel, the same way a store shelf does, which is why something like a Twinkie is loaded with preservatives and fillers that keep it good for years and let it ship anywhere. Sure, one Twinkie won't kill you, but nobody feels great after eating them two or three days a week for years.
The slow parts of church are more like whole food. Scripture read aloud at length, a sermon that takes twenty minutes to land, or sitting in silence together don't present well on a feed, because they take work, the washing and cutting and cooking kind. They're also what actually feeds you.
But the clip is really the last step in a longer process, and that process starts on Sunday morning.
•••
In a lot of ways, the modern church in America can feel like a factory. A factory is built to produce the same thing over and over, so it runs on a formula that scales efficiently, with the same ingredients going in the same order.
In the same way, you could walk into many Protestant or non-denominational churches in the U.S. and get the same product. You get greeted, the lights go down and the band plays a few songs, then you sit and face forward and listen to one person talk at you for about forty-five minutes. There's another song and everybody goes home.
That's about as American as it gets.
We’re good at industrializing things, taking what used to be made slowly by hand and building a line that can turn out a lot of it fast. It’s no wonder somewhere along the way the church got the same treatment.

It's a good formula at what it's built for. It produces a lot of salvations, a lot of programs, and a lot of Christians who know their way around a Sunday. I'm thankful for plenty of what it's produced. But a formula is built to turn out the same thing every time, and I'm becoming more certain that spiritual formation doesn't work like that.
What worries me most is that the factory doesn't only turn out clips and reels and shareable things. It also turns out Christians, one after another, like a conveyor belt. Some come off the belt formed and some come off performing, and from the outside it can be hard to tell the difference.
Then those same Christians go home and gorge on the clips the factory made. Eat enough of those and you start to think that's what faith is supposed to look like, small and quick and easy to share.
You can probably picture somebody. They can quote three pastors they've never met but have never sat with a whole chapter of Scripture on their own. They feel closest to God when the lights are down and the band is playing, and the rest of the week they get by on whatever shows up in their feed. Some weeks that's been me.
I think it's making the church sick.
•••
The crowd in John 6 had the same appetite. Jesus feeds more than five thousand people with a few loaves and fish, and the crowd loves it. They chase him across the lake the next day, and he tells them they're following him because they ate their fill.

He says he’s the bread of life, and that unless they eat his flesh and drink his blood they have no life in them. It’s a wild thing to say to a group of people. John says many of his disciples turned back and no longer walked with him. I’d be lying if I said I wouldn’t maybe be one of the guys quietly backing toward the boats.
Jesus doesn't chase after them or soften the teaching so it lands better. He turns to the twelve and asks if they want to leave too, and Peter says, where would we go, you have the words of eternal life.
The crowd wanted more bread. Jesus offered them something that takes a lifetime to digest.
Jeff touched on this a few months back in his post on sermon-addicted evangelicalism, where he pointed out that we're taking in truth faster than we can actually live it.
I think the factory has a lot to do with that.
•••
Maybe it isn’t killing the church. It looks like it’s working, and God keeps using it, and I’m thankful for that. But I think it’s teaching a lot of us to mistake being full for being fed, and that’s a hard thing to notice from the inside.
The hopeful part is that the gospel doesn't need a factory. It was around long before anybody industrialized anything, and it's survived worse than an algorithm.
A factory needs everything to come out the same, but what the Holy Spirit is doing in one person is different from what he's doing in the person next to them, and that kind of work is slow.
I think the church's job is to help each person figure out what the Lord wants for them, even when it runs against the formula.
The real question is what our rhythm is training people to want.
These days, I'd rather help somebody find the bread that takes a lifetime to digest than hand them another bite.
Become a member of The Vineyard
Through monthly support, members make space for reflection, honesty, and the slow work of formation that Voice & Vine was created to nurture. Learn more

Ronnie lives in McKinney, TX with his wife Dannie and their two daughters. He runs a creative agency called GoodFolks, helping brands and organizations tell stories that matter. Alongside his work there, he co-created Voice & Vine as a way to explore faith, creativity, and healing through honest conversation and reflection. His journey has been shaped by a love for building meaningful things—both in business and in life—and by a growing desire to slow down and return to what’s true. Whether leading creative teams or sharing life around the table, Ronnie continues to learn what it means to live from a place of faith, humility, and hope.


